Below is a list of the top and leading Italian Restaurants in Hamilton. To help you find the best Italian Restaurants located near you in Hamilton, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.
Hamilton’s Best Italian Restaurants:
The top rated Italian Restaurants in Hamilton are:
- La Spaghett Pasta House – elevated Italian fare in a polished dining room with 30+ customizable, artisanal pasta sauces
- La Cantina – classy, family-owned Italian joint since 1998 with wood-fired pizza, select mains & outdoor seating
- Caro – modern Italian cuisine & cocktails, plus brunch, featured in an airy, white-walled setting
- Giuseppe’s – stalwart outpost serving traditional Italian dishes in a white-tablecloth setting
- Maccheroni Cucina Alfresco – long-time eatery with a courtyard patio serving classic Italian comfort dishes in a warm atmosphere
La Spaghett Pasta House
La Spaghett Pasta House has learned to appreciate their fantastic regulars, who make serving their neighborhood so much fun. In addition to their famous pasta, which are created with only the freshest ingredients acquired from local markets, diners may choose premium salads and crostinis. They’re excited to continue to strengthen their existing customer relationships while also meeting new regulars. Additionally, individuals with a sweet tooth can indulge in their vast selection of Dufflet’s cakes and pastries. Another wonderful addition to any social gathering is traveling the world through their ever-changing assortment of wines from private vineyards, many of which are not available at the LCBO.
Address: 970 Upper James St, Hamilton, ON L9C 3A5
Phone: (905) 318 8211
“All I can say is WOW!!!!!! I have never in my life had pasta this good! Absolutely incredible fresh food and such flavourful food! Shannon was our server and she was amazing! Could not ask for a better experience! Will absolutely be back!” – Samantha Hutchinson
La Cantina features a nice outside terrace that is available periodically. La Cantina isn’t your standard fine dining Italian restaurant in Hamilton. They’re a family-owned and operated restaurant. Decisions made here are always made with the goal of providing excellent service to their existing clients while also attracting new ones. The modest origins of La Cantina Ristorante began in 1986, in a charming spot off Queen Street on Hamilton’s west side. Maurizio worked tirelessly and passionately towards his goal, beginning to develop La Cantina’s success formulas alongside Gilda, his business partner, and mentor.
Address: 60 Walnut St S, Hamilton, ON L8N 2L1
Phone: (905) 521 8989
“Had the chicken pizza and calamari here and it was fantastic. Staff was very friendly and attentive. The restaurant was very clean and staff wore mask the whole time. Would definitely come back here again.” – Oliver Delima
Caro is restauranteur Cory Tower’s first labor of love. Their wonderful customers, friends, family, and community will be able to enjoy this restaurant for many years to come. It’s a bright and airy location that serves delicious modern Italian cuisine and drinks. It is a place you can call home, with kind employees, a welcoming atmosphere, and plenty of opportunities to laugh. In the winter, it’s snug and warm place to be, and in the summer, it’s a fantastic patio spot for those hot Ontario summers.
Address: 4 Ottawa St N, Hamilton, ON L8H 3Y7
Phone: (905) 312 4545
“I went to eat lunch with my two kids. It was my first time there and everything was amazing! The price, the service and the food was spectacular! The two young guys who served us were very polite, attentive and professional. I highly recommend this restaurant. The kids and I will be back as we love the food.” – Carolina Corado
Giuseppe’s is Hamilton’s go-to spot for genuine, home-cooked Italian food. Located in a restored Victorian-style mansion from the early 1900s. The LCBO has fully licensed this casual fine dining business, which has plenty of parking. With pristine white linen, hardwood floors, and candlelight, the restaurant exudes an elegant, inviting atmosphere. Giuseppe’s Italian Cuisine & Pizza is operated by executive chefs and proprietors Giuseppe & Gerardo Imperiale, both hotel and restaurant graduates with over 20 years of experience.
Address: 762 King St E, Hamilton, ON L8M 1A5
Phone: (905) 525 3334
“Delicious, authentic Italian food, made from scratch. The chef(s) clearly love what they do. The food takes a while so bring some company for good conversation while you wait. I’ve driven by this place probably hundreds of times without realizing there was a restaurant hidden in this vintage Hamilton home on King Street. Now I’ll definitely stop by again. Best Italian food I’ve had in years. Thanks for a great evening Guiseppe’s!” – Vikas Jha
Maccheroni Cucina Alfresco
Maccheroni Cucina Alfresco is a popular choice for catering and event hosting in the area. They can easily handle parties of up to 40 people in our facility. Their early education included the value of hard labor and a passion for food, as they did in most Italian homes. Along with a passion for food came a commitment to family and friends, particularly around mealtime.
Their belief that delicious cuisine brings people together around the table inspired me to create Maccheroni Cucina Alfresco. Maccheroni’s, which has been open since 1994, caters to a wide range of customers, from business clients and visitors to families and friends. Moreover, they provide traditional and classic Italian meals, as well as some of their family’s treasured recipes.
Address: 1560 Main St W, Hamilton, ON L8S 1E7
Phone: (905) 527 6422
“I was able to order a delicious vegan meal. I ordered the Mediterranean pasta and held the cheese. My husband enjoyed his seafood pasta. Service by Margarita was outstanding. She made me a beautiful negroni cocktail and even waiting while I checked the internet for the exact recipe. A nice touch to have the owner check on us and all the tables to see if we were enjoying our meals. The ambiance in the restaurant is lovely too. We will definitely be back again and highly recommend.” – Kerry Armstrong