5 Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto🥇

Below is a list of the top and leading Italian restaurants in Toronto. To help you find the Italian restaurants located near you in Toronto, we put together our list based on this rating points list.

Toronto’s Best Italian Restaurants:

The top-rated Italian restaurants in Toronto:

• CARISMA – one of Toronto’s Best Italian Restaurants.
• Trattoria Taverniti – a quaint and charming Italian restaurant.
• Giulietta – ranked number five in En Route Magazine’s Canada’s Best New Restaurants list.
• Pizza e Pazzi – custom-built brick wood-burning oven pizzas.
• Rosina – traditional Italian cuisine at the highest level.

CARISMA

First on the list is CARISMA. They pride themselves on being one of Toronto’s Best Italian Restaurants and remains a favourite amongst its long-standing loyal clientele. Its owners got a long history of being in the business, including restaurants such as Barolo and Il Mulino, Carisma offers the same authentic Italian food and quality service they are known and loved for. Carisma is able to accommodate more than their previous location with two private rooms, larger dining space, and separate bar area. Carisma is described in one word as what the Italians like to refer to as “accoglienza”, the epitome of hospitality, a warm welcome that only comes with experience, heart and lots of Carisma.

Products/ Services:  

Traditional Italian Food

LOCATION:

Address: 15 Toronto St, Toronto, ON M5C 2E3

Phone: 416 864 7373

Website: carismarestaurant.com

REVIEWS:

“This is a great fine dining experience and the food really hits the spot. I went for my birthday. The presentation was beautiful , the taste was impeccable. I had scallops for an appetizer and it was decadent. The lamb chops were wonderful and cooked at a perfect temperature throughout. I was very satisfied with my meal. The pear martini was also good with fresh pears. The customer service was also great. I would recommend this place and visit again.” – Oacia Fair

Trattoria Taverniti

Trattoria Taverniti’s story begins almost 90 years ago in Monasterace Calabria, Italy. The mother’s owner was born in 1930 and learned to cook from her father. Everything she was taught, everything she saw, she reproduced. She found her passion in food and came to Canada in 1956. After finding the perfect location in Little Italy, they opened Trattoria Taverniti. The place is quaint and charming with exposed brick, checkered table cloths, and old barn wood. It is a comfortable restaurant that is great for mid-afternoon lunch breaks, dinner with friends and family, and sipping wine later in the evening.

Products/ Services:  

Pizzas & Pasta Dishes

LOCATION:

Address: 591 College St, Toronto, ON M6G 1B2

Phone: 416 537 0078

Website: tavernitis.ca/

REVIEWS:

“My favourite Italian restaurant in Toronto! Reasonably priced and great menu. Gnocchi is fantastic. They are open during COVID typically Thursday-Sunday.” – Dee Jay

Giulietta

Rob Rossi his five-year-old critically acclaimed restaurant, Bestellen, to achieve his dreams of opening the sleek, authentic Italian eatery, Giulietta in the spring of 2018. Giulietta chef’s bar offers seating right in the heart of the action. Just months after opening, Giulietta was ranked number five in En Route Magazine’s Canada’s Best New Restaurants list. It’s Rossi’s second restaurant and the first he has opened with David Minicucci. The chef’s bar is all Rossi, it plays to his gregarious nature and pays homage to the television show he stars in on TLN by the same name.

Products/ Services:  

Wood-fired Pizza, House-made Pasta, Vegetable and Seafood Plates, etc.

LOCATION:

Address: 972 College St, Toronto, ON M6H 1A5

Phone: 416 964 0606

Website: giu.ca/

REVIEWS:

“Fantastic restaurant. Food and drinks were phenomenal. Service is great and portions are good sizes. One of my new favourite restaurants in Toronto. Highly recommend!” – Joe J

Pizza e Pazzi

Pizza e Pazzi custom-built brick wood-burning oven guarantees every pizza to come out mouth-watering, but their homemade pasta prepared by the owner and the skilled chef of twenty years is bound to leave guests unable to put down their utensils until every bite is finished. Authentic Neapolitan Pizza is a thing of beauty designed to delight with every bite. Its ingredients consist of a palette of delirious flavors. The tart tinge of the San Marzano tomatoes adds a sweet quality to the soft, blistered, flame-licked bed of dough. It is then topped with any and all of your chosen delights to create a work of art for guests’ consumption.

Products/ Services:  

Authentic Neapolitan Pizza

LOCATION:

Address: 1182 St Clair Ave W, Toronto, ON M6E 1B4

Phone: 416 651 9999

Website: pizzaepazzi.ca/

REVIEWS:

“Pizza 🍕 lovers rejoice! Authentic Italian pizza made in their brick-wood burning oven! delicious, thin crust pizza made to perfection. Choices other than pizza includes: antipasto, insalate, pasta, and risotto. Prices range from $7-$24” – Ella

Rosina

Last on the list is Rosina. It is a welcoming restaurant located in the heart of downtown Toronto. Rosina serves authentic, homemade Italian food with recipes that have been handed down through generations. Guests can enjoy the real taste of Italy, from the owner’s family to theirs. Guests can enjoy traditional Italian cuisine at the highest level. The quality lies in the composition of the best products while offering traditional and original cuisine, a true Italian experience passed down from generations. Rosina is a place of enjoyment and relaxation at one of the most warming places in the city.

Products/ Services:  

Antipasti, Insalata, Pasta, Secondi, Pizze, Dolci, etc.

LOCATION:

Address: 740A King St W, Toronto, ON M5V 1N3

Phone: 416 519 2994

Website: ristoranterosina.ca/

REVIEWS:

“One of the best Italian restaurants my husband and I have been to in downtown Toronto! We love the mushroom tagliatelle and seafood pasta! Really friendly manager and staff-with great wine (when we were able to dine-in!). We order take-out from Rosina about once a week now! Authentic Italian, fairly priced and delicious!” – Alia Alma